The implausible queer thriller “They/Them” flips the script on horror movies beginning with its intelligent/devious opening scene involving a lone driver within the woods at night time. It is one in every of many indications that thrice Oscar-nominated author John Logan (“Gladiator,” “Penny Dreadful”) — making a assured directorial debut — is toying with viewers. Even with a pointed reference to “Friday the thirteenth,” nothing in “They/Them” is kind of what it appears — a lot of its characters have secrets and techniques — and that’s what make this artful movie so rattling enjoyable.
The story unfolds at Whistler Camp,” the place a bunch of LGBTQIA+ youth have been despatched to be “straightened out.” Although the director, Owen Whistler (Kevin Bacon) tells campers it is a “secure area,” it’s, actually, fairly harmful. Not solely is Whistler a conversion remedy retreat, however a masked killer is stalking the grounds.
“They/Them” creates a way of unease slowly. Upon arrival, the trans and non-binary Jordan (Theo Germaine), who makes use of they/them pronouns — as in “They cannot imagine they’re at this f**king camp” — requests an all-gender cabin when the campers are assigned to “boy” and “woman” bunks. Owen, suitably challenged, sees Jordan goes to be adversarial. A later scene the place Cora (Carrie Preston), the camp’s therapist, will get inside Jordan’s head is without doubt one of the movie’s most insidious.
But this tough second is adopted by one of many movie’s most energizing sequences. As Alexandra (Quei Tann) counsels a pensive Jordan, “Change the voices in your head. Make them such as you as a substitute,” the whole cabin breaks out singing and dancing to Pink’s anthem, “F**kin’ Perfect.” They bond and insurgent towards change/being modified on this empowering second.
This theme is effectively developed all through “They/Them.” As the campers are assigned to binary, heteronormative actions — the blokes do athletics and go taking pictures, and the ladies make craft initiatives and pies — the youth resist and defy. When Owen is in search of a person with “killer intuition,” he asks the musical-theater loving Toby (Austin Crute) to shoot one thing. However, Toby is unable to do it, and his fellow campers together with Stu (Cooper Koch), and Alexandra come to his help. Moreover, when Jordan is challenged by Zane (Boone Platt) — the camp’s previously homosexual now “straight because the day is lengthy” athletic director — to a goal competitors, Jordan proves to be a grasp marksperson. These episodes present extra character improvement than stress.
Theo Germaine as Jordan, Boone Platt as Zanein “They/Them” (Photo by: Josh Stringer/Blumhouse (Josh Stringer/Blumhouse)
Likewise, Kim (Anna Lore), a lesbian camper, excels at baking, which inspires actions counselor Sarah (Hayley Griffith) to return on to her, which is downright creepy. Kim is comforted by the bisexual Veronica (Monique Kim), and so they interact in a passionate second on the dock.
The intercourse scene between Kim and Veronica provides extra pleasure than peril. The characters who’re punished (i.e., killed) for having intercourse are ones who behave inappropriately and inauthentically — as when one man is taking a look at selfies of Stu in a Speedo with the intention to interact in intercourse with a feminine camper.
Yet it’s when a personality seduces a camper below false pretenses that “They/Them” focuses on the horrors of aversion remedy with the character receiving electrical shocks to snuff out their same-sex wishes. (Earlier Jordan discovers a set of outdated images that includes equally traumatized victims.) The electroshock system is, after all, used to kill in a single scene, as if to emphasise the hurt of such therapy.
It’s not a spoiler to disclose that that assassin is somebody performing towards the hateful apply of conversion remedy and justified in eager to shut down each conversion remedy middle, even when killing is an excessive technique to obtain that lofty aim.
“They/Them” nevertheless, is comparatively delicate on the bloodletting, which could disappoint gore hounds, however delicate viewers can be grateful — save one scene involving an animal’s loss of life. (It’s implied not proven.) Logan principally retains the suspense at a simmer. An early scene involving a feminine character being caught within the bathe, offers extra shock than splatter. Generally, when a sufferer is dispatched, it’s fast and environment friendly, and advances the killer’s trigger.
As Jordan, Theo Germaine delivers a powerful efficiency as a result of they’re endearing and use their wits and abilities to outlive. At one level, Jordan wryly observes that issues, “Don’t really feel proper. There needs to be extra Bible-thumping and queer-bashing,” and takes cost as our bodies pile up. Likewise, when a personality assigned with a tough process claims they’re a Black transgender lady, so that they haven’t any concern, it’s arduous to not giggle and applaud.
Want a each day wrap-up of all of the information and commentary Salon has to supply? Subscribe to our morning e-newsletter, Crash Course.
“They/Them” is notable for casting authentically and having trans, non-binary, homosexual, lesbian and queer actors taking part in trans, non-binary, homosexual, lesbian and queer characters. (Similarly, the latest “Fire Island” and the forthcoming “Bros” have largely genuine queer casts.) It does elevate the movie as a result of the characters really feel actual, even once they play up stereotypes. Austin Crute could also be sassy and flamboyant, however as Toby connects with Stu — who’s initially homophobic — their friendship feels candy, not compelled. As Stu, Cooper Koch is convincing as a hunky frat boy, which is why as he drops his guard and turns into extra self-accepting, he’s extra sympathetic. Koch makes his transformation compelling.
Monique Kim as Veronica, Anna Lore as Kim in “They/Them” (Josh Stringer/Blumhouse)
The movie additionally offers Monique Kim some alternative moments as Veronica. Her droll line deliveries — comparable to a remark she makes when Kim craves a grimy martini — are amusing, and it’s pleasing to see her relationship with Anna Lore’s Kim develop over the course of the movie.
Logan additionally lets the straight actors dig into their components. Kevin Bacon appears to relish his position because the camp’s director alternating between pleasant and fiendish. Alas, Carrie Preston shouldn’t be given sufficient to do, however she is pitch-perfect in her remedy periods. And, as Molly, the camp’s nurse, Anna Chlumsky is likeable as a reluctant ally for the youth.
“They/Them” is a great and savvy movie that demonstrates the worth of placing queer heroes within the horror style in addition to the damaging results of conversion remedy and never permitting folks to be who they’re.
“They/Them” is now streaming on Peacock. Watch a trailer by way of YouTube.
about this matter